How does liquid restaking technically differ from liquid staking?

ソース: LBank日時: 2025-03-19 01:48:37

Understanding Liquid Restaking vs. Liquid Staking

As the blockchain ecosystem continues to evolve, various staking mechanisms have emerged to enhance user participation and network security. Among these, liquid staking and liquid restaking are two prominent methods that offer unique benefits and functionalities. This article delves into the technical differences between liquid restaking and traditional liquid staking, providing a comprehensive understanding of each approach.

What is Liquid Staking?

Liquid staking is a process where users lock up their tokens in a validator or staking pool to contribute to the validation of transactions within a blockchain network. In return for this commitment, users receive a corresponding staking token that represents their staked assets. These tokens can be utilized for governance purposes, such as voting on network upgrades.

However, one significant drawback of traditional liquid staking is that the original tokens remain illiquid during the lock-up period. Users cannot transfer or utilize these assets for other purposes until they are unstaked, which can limit flexibility in managing their investments.

The Concept of Liquid Restaking

Liquid restaking introduces an innovative alternative by allowing users to stake their tokens with greater flexibility. Unlike traditional liquid staking, which often requires longer lock-up periods, liquid restaking typically involves shorter durations with fixed terms. After this period ends, users can withdraw their tokens while still receiving rewards from the staked assets.

This method enhances liquidity significantly compared to its predecessor since users retain some level of access to their funds during the lock-up phase—albeit with certain restrictions imposed by the third-party service managing this process.

Key Technical Differences Between Liquid Restaking and Liquid Staking

1. Lock-Up Period

A primary distinction between these two approaches lies in their respective lock-up periods:

  • Liquid Staking: Typically features longer lock-up periods where funds remain inaccessible until unstaked.
  • Liquid Restaking: Offers shorter locking durations that allow for quicker withdrawal after completion of set terms.

2. Liquidity During Lock-Up

The liquidity aspect also varies significantly between both methods:

  • Liquid Staking: Tokens are generally locked away completely; thus they cannot be used or transferred during this time frame.
  • Liquid Restaking: Users maintain some degree of liquidity as they can utilize or trade certain derivatives linked to their staked assets even while locked up under specific conditions set by third-party services.

3. Management Structure

The management processes involved in each method differ notably as well:

  • Liquid Staking:: Often requires direct involvement from users who must manage validators themselves or navigate complex interfaces without external assistance.
  • Liquid Restaking:: Generally facilitated through third-party services designed specifically for ease-of-use; these platforms handle all technical aspects related to both initial stakes and subsequent withdrawals on behalf of users who prefer not engaging directly with intricate protocols themselves.

The Advantages of Each Approach

A Closer Look at Benefits Offered by Traditional Liquid Stacking

  • Security : By participating directly via validator nodes , participants contribute towards securing networks against malicious attacks .
  • Governance Participation : Holding native governance tokens allows stakeholders influence over future developments within ecosystems .
  • Potentially Higher Rewards : Longer-term commitments may yield increased returns due higher reward rates associated extended stakes .
Technical Study
現物先物
USDTUSDCLTsBTCETHSTABLECOINS
取引ペア価格変動率
87234.43
0.75%
2053.08
0.29%
629.0
-1.73%
141.95
1.93%
0.00265
1.15%
0.9998
-0.01%
2.4412
0.91%
3.605
-1.85%
2.4548
4.34%
0.3902
1.06%
4.617
-0.13%
11.45
0.44%
0.6704
-1.47%
0.000710
-7.43%
0.000889
-27.72%
0.000001292
3.19%
0.004950
1.02%
1.7028
183.80%
0.3594
259.40%
0.04122
106.10%
2.3853
90.82%
0.004834
101.58%
0.003373
-65.18%
0.000363
-56.32%
0.00709
-14.99%
0.000506
28.75%
0.01849
42.23%
0.000551
14.08%
0.04814
1.56%
0.0005757
3.04%
0.002609
-8.78%
0.002447
-19.48%
0.1385
-20.36%
0.007004
-11.15%
0.05573
-3.46%
0.000009183
3.99%
0.01840
-3.82%
0.001473
-0.07%
0.002693
6.78%
0.004247
-14.74%
0.0003529
12.60%
0.002859
6.60%
0.004984
-27.38%
0.017673
-4.40%
0.000540
-0.37%
0.0004298
-28.09%
0.003393
-20.16%
0.14650
5.03%
1.356
-3.97%
0.0013010
-3.47%
0.1493
12.26%
1453.3781
0.62%
3.65061
-2.94%
2067854.9706799
3.23%
61000.87585
18.87%
3182.0000
0.06%
0.00083546
10.01%
3681.43998
-19.93%
0.45042
-29.16%
33876.95399
44.33%
0.00000011430
1.42%
0.0000556
-41.35%
0.005038
-38.31%
54.00724
-0.37%
0.0000006247
-16.87%
153.88472
-0.02%
0.0000007881
7.18%
32.0317
4.09%
14.3740
-12.15%
6.5018
-1.99%
0.1674
-1.18%
0.01906
-0.88%
5.894936
3.59%
1.99310
1.29%
0.07333
-0.49%
0.666333
0.80%
0.2041
0.20%
0.01487
11.55%
8.2890
0.14%
0.000000000000068
58.14%
0.009748
0.00%
0.006584
0.78%
0.6226
-0.14%
0.00000000000105
191.67%
0.000695
0.43%
1.5499
-0.96%
0.01902
6.85%
0.23289
0.00%
1.1043
0.00%
0.000027093
0.20%
0.183313
-1.90%
0.2621
-1.69%
4.1798
-58.20%
0.63531
-1.26%
0.2748
0.66%
0.061454
0.67%
0.1517
6.91%
528.0000
0.19%
0.005421
-1.40%
0.077365
5.82%
0.0030870
-0.05%
0.00000020
-60.00%
0.4561
-1.89%
0.0013027
2.65%
1.3791
-1.50%
1.2423
0.69%
0.7074
-0.41%
1.0513
0.23%
0.00006991
-3.32%
0.77
-8.33%
0.02568
-11.90%
0.01508
-0.13%
0.106400
-0.93%
0.1984
16.16%
0.00077445
12.27%
0.007945
1.33%
0.00341605
0.78%
0.001546
-4.57%
96.9144
-0.12%
0.00546
0.18%
0.16866
0.40%
8.5511
-0.50%
213.84
-5.58%
10.3612
0.43%
0.00001083
-13.84%
0.0120
0.00%
0.04073
-11.90%
0.04107
-1.39%
0.8544
0.09%
0.0263
-0.38%
0.024461
37.83%
0.0914
0.77%
0.19097
4.53%
0.003329
-6.78%
0.0003131
-0.57%
4.5090
-14.21%
0.0006125
1.83%
0.006433
2.83%
0.000000725
15.08%
0.0422
3.18%
0.8176
-12.05%
0.001916
4.76%
1.1617
-0.22%
0.00217
4.83%
0.00005256
0.19%
3.1380
0.33%
0.00305
0.66%
0.1675
-1.30%
0.02048
-0.34%
0.00000004433
5.72%
1.2105
0.12%
0.00215600
1.89%
0.000000001174
-17.09%
0.0030837
-0.36%
0.26910
1.97%
0.5333
24.60%
0.057359
-3.18%
0.00257
2.39%
0.013733
1.16%
0.03009
0.00%
0.6256
-3.22%
0.002510
-2.18%
0.66675
-0.15%
2.6877
2.24%
0.5034
-1.26%
3.7925
-0.07%
1.6242
4.65%
0.001514
-0.20%
0.00002850
1.06%
0.00003425
0.03%
0.045770
0.84%
0.2098
5.22%
1.5950
0.35%
0.0003307
-0.27%
0.13626
-8.83%
0.02670
0.75%
0.0260
1.17%
0.00186
-12.68%
0.2631
64.33%
238.5800
-0.44%
0.018792
-4.13%
0.000815
-0.97%
0.025005
0.30%
3.4527
-0.43%
0.115770
0.00%
105.0865
-1.48%
0.6270
-38.93%
0.00004382
0.00%
7.4861
-2.32%
1.46
5.80%
0.0007175
0.01%
0.00000261
0.00%
0.04888
-0.12%
0.000003918
1.11%
5.915
2.37%
41.27138
64.07%
0.56541
7.50%
48.7123
-0.12%
0.7427
2.36%
0.00000001345
2.13%
0.0023833
1.24%
0.01204
0.08%
0.1009
5.99%
0.00004692
0.30%
0.0000131789
10.79%
0.2281
0.62%
0.0003293
-2.37%
0.002098
-0.71%
0.00000000003371
1.08%
0.01907
1.22%
0.3354
-0.77%
0.1476
-0.20%
0.000000001405
2.26%
0.00001455
7.62%
0.00000655
0.00%
0.0004314
-22.19%
0.005407
17.54%
0.0008397
14.73%
0.00542
1.31%
0.0025160
2.08%
0.6158
5.72%
26.3201
-0.71%
0.0001640
-4.65%
0.04598
2.27%
0.007522
2.13%
0.04175
-1.04%
0.370
-1.07%
93.62
1.20%
0.38629
23.03%
18.5460
17.72%
3.0816
-1.09%
0.116100
-2.60%
0.024958
27.24%
0.4603
11.24%
0.02240
-0.09%
0.001818
-0.11%
0.0260
4.84%
0.0982
-4.94%
0.0001834
2.29%
0.01742
-1.53%
0.12368
0.32%
0.00713
-2.60%
0.05382
-5.60%
0.1721
6.76%
0.012811
37.89%
0.02147
-0.74%
0.024527
0.00%
0.02750
-3.10%
0.0011342
-0.26%
0.05440
-0.15%
0.009327
0.12%
0.002778
2.28%
0.0006407
0.55%
0.1311
-0.46%
0.020231
0.25%
93.257
1.92%
0.0002826
0.43%
0.00001969
-5.70%
0.2100
3.86%
0.00010115
0.25%
209.200
-0.38%
0.1782
-19.95%
0.0005833
0.21%
0.04833
-16.34%
11.5645
0.01%
0.002239
-5.17%
0.226
-3.00%
0.026880
5.37%
0.013725
2.05%
0.01898
0.11%
0.004944
-0.22%
0.0016460
-0.44%
0.002355
-7.14%
1.7437
1.32%
0.16383
-10.14%
0.0000850
1.67%
0.00234
-2.09%
0.00501
-3.47%
0.0010006
-0.03%
0.00000072
1.41%
0.11545
-14.81%
0.03285
1.08%
0.0288
-72.57%
0.15144
-3.45%
0.002854
0.67%
8.9440
0.01%
0.0625
6.47%
0.00000815
2.39%
11.09
0.54%
0.00285
-1.38%
0.10364
1.01%
0.00052
-1.89%
0.008091
14.13%
0.000001415
-2.82%
0.0001285
-3.67%
0.000640
0.00%
0.6799
-12.83%
0.1271
4.78%
0.002578
-3.12%
0.00017747
-5.01%
0.00048
0.00%
0.00083399
-0.55%
0.0000013
-69.77%
15.40
2.60%
0.00001397
1.67%
0.01590
0.00%
2.0109
0.83%
0.00522
5.45%
0.00000494
1.65%
0.0000745
-40.16%
0.0003753
3.96%
3.8564
9.85%
0.0000885
1.37%
0.018683
-5.68%
0.0000000364
0.83%
5.87
-1.51%
0.01940
-5.78%
0.000003291
7.55%
0.6962
-79.52%
0.014699
-13.60%
3.8858
0.15%
0.001330
0.83%
0.000002325
6.21%
0.0000000034
-10.53%
0.0783
-0.38%
6.28
4.67%
0.19413
0.91%
0.05970
0.84%
0.00394
-0.51%
0.05194
-13.16%
0.003303
-3.48%
0.002100
-18.16%
0.68181
-0.02%
22.64
5.25%
0.5419
0.48%
0.01787
-5.25%
0.923
-1.39%
0.5998
-0.03%
0.008263
5.33%
0.00009712
-0.16%
0.06152
-20.36%
0.48639
0.44%
0.639
-16.80%
0.007209
18.67%
0.00018709
0.65%
0.01072
17.54%
2.476
-8.33%
0.00321
10.31%
0.1772
1.84%
0.0000550
-21.65%
0.002450
2.47%
0.000750
0.54%
1.0685
-3.49%
0.00007740
-2.04%
0.007997
15.35%
0.036101
0.93%
0.6031
0.18%
6.4003
0.00%
0.1384
-0.07%
0.00725
4.32%
0.0000216
-17.24%
0.1512
0.27%
0.2369
3.04%
0.9225
5.24%
0.00226
22.16%
0.006752
-1.01%
0.01668
0.18%
0.0059
-1.67%
0.000006306
-15.85%
0.0931
7.01%
34.0585
-0.22%
0.6336
6.72%
43.86
-0.63%
1.0002
0.03%
0.0323
6.95%
11.8210
3.88%
0.04617
-2.27%
0.8764
-3.72%
183.13
-2.47%
0.00001542
-0.71%
0.002575
3.17%
1.206
-2.82%
90.8018
0.05%
0.002350
1.34%
0.000713
36.33%
1.976
0.61%
0.1921
-2.64%
0.03138
1.23%
0.000680
4.62%
0.06089
4.73%
0.00778
24.48%
0.00000016593
7.56%
0.0000000047
-2.08%
0.00003211
0.82%
0.005111
-10.40%
0.1078
0.00%
4.3871
0.41%
0.560
2.00%
0.02849
19.01%
0.0108
1.89%
0.00460
0.00%
0.00530000
-5.36%
0.0000392
-7.98%
0.10760
6.64%
0.0017
0.00%
0.44997
-5.41%
0.17335
-1.96%
6.063
0.23%
0.4182
15.33%
0.000130
0.00%
0.0085130
-2.39%
0.542
-0.73%
0.0000001150
-19.92%
0.07693
0.39%
3.022
3.32%
0.0015
-6.25%
3.0000
-0.01%
0.001500
-16.67%
0.01251
0.56%
0.1814
0.78%
0.001007
-11.20%
0.002241
-1.75%
0.4137
4.10%
0.7934
2.08%
0.001000
0.00%
0.012425
0.06%
0.2933
2.02%
0.003531
-9.81%
0.2332
6.92%
0.000000000350
-1.96%
0.002662
7.30%
2.1111
0.00%
0.01836
1.55%
0.01913
15.24%
0.00006437
0.39%
0.7969
1.01%
0.00000152
4.83%
0.3497
-0.06%
0.00017186
0.00%
0.00813
10.46%
4.080
6.83%
0.02657
2.00%
0.2804
1.34%
0.000556
-1.59%
0.0009399
-0.12%
1.6019
-0.37%
0.00047
0.00%
0.2132
4.25%
0.002375
11.24%
0.000393
4.52%
0.00006725
0.25%
0.00000001393
10.47%
0.00000614
0.00%
267.4
0.87%
0.0002307
0.70%
0.012713
-21.47%
62.0000
-11.43%
6.945
-0.39%
6.142
2.67%
0.08000
-3.04%
0.0036659
0.07%
1.049
-0.76%
0.85492
-0.32%
0.0243
-2.41%
0.4627
-0.81%
0.0000851
-1.05%
0.005989
-21.31%
19.21
-7.11%
0.0000019875
7.71%
0.7230
-8.79%
0.02088
15.42%
0.00002440
-0.29%
3.119
0.22%
0.01817
12.44%
7.39
1.23%
0.00057113
3.12%
0.000000052261
2.50%
2.959
5.04%
0.09818
3.45%
0.1426
1.13%
0.09201
-3.57%
1.396
12.04%
0.0317
-0.31%
2.1029
2.44%
0.9551
6.50%
0.013361
-3.07%
0.005483
2.95%
2.858
-0.56%
0.000197
4.23%
0.7549
5.82%
1.574
3.96%
1.1405
11.88%
0.002781
6.06%
0.011547
-1.11%
332.5
1.22%
20.60
59.81%
0.01592
-2.09%
0.5153
2.73%
0.000509
0.00%
0.0240
-0.41%
0.000649
-16.04%
0.907
0.67%
0.01924
-0.31%
0.2079
0.34%
0.04600
31.81%
0.007376
-15.79%
0.005493
0.44%
0.00002656
-1.63%
0.2087
6.86%
0.00240
0.00%
0.00039
95.00%
0.0000609
0.16%
0.00150
7.91%
9.96
-0.70%
0.12773
0.49%
0.0099
4.21%
0.00758
1.07%
0.00000340
-2.02%
0.2467
-0.04%
0.1178
1.12%
8.42
-1.98%
0.0796
90.43%
0.4229
15.29%
3.650
0.08%
0.0124266
0.56%
0.1187
6.46%
0.01096
-1.62%
0.00438
0.46%
0.00508
-0.20%
0.1001
0.00%
0.000763
-18.05%
0.1098
-4.60%
0.6221
-6.13%
0.0020
0.00%
0.03971
-2.65%
0.000329
28.52%
0.3959
23.80%
0.009390
4.33%
0.00140
0.00%
0.004906
36.09%
0.4508
0.29%
0.0005456
-14.79%
0.03771
5.39%
0.000163
0.62%
0.00455
2.71%
0.0000000389
0.78%
0.001359
37.41%
9.13
-0.87%
0.00065
-1.52%
0.006900
15.81%
0.000361
7.44%
0.006022
-0.43%
0.01838
2.80%
15.75
-2.96%
0.0635
2.58%
18.30
0.99%
0.3140
-1.41%
0.0007056
7.46%
0.000853
1.31%
0.01433
0.63%
0.00292
-4.58%
0.03618
-0.41%
0.004560
61.36%
0.00521
1.56%
4.794
-3.15%
0.7054
0.27%
0.00028535
0.30%
0.008076
-2.09%
0.000119
0.00%
0.02049
22.11%
0.988
1.65%
0.5307
0.89%
0.002653
-12.04%
0.000000001497
0.00%
0.0002652
-8.68%
0.01563
3.37%
0.0000000533
2.70%
0.03627
-6.16%
0.001912
1.06%
0.00016951
8.78%
22.05
-4.26%
0.3071
2.23%
1.1780668
1.19%
0.1537
-1.16%
0.1888
5.18%
0.0000541
26.40%
0.003637
-5.51%
0.1041
2.56%
0.002133
-2.96%
0.004423
2.12%
0.004902
-2.74%
0.0934
2.19%
1.7666
0.27%
0.004979
-0.26%
0.066754
1.00%
0.00000477
5.07%
0.1271
-0.78%
0.0003060
49.93%
0.2362
11.52%
5.46
1.87%
0.00746
3.90%
0.001641
14.68%
0.0694
0.43%
0.00370985
11.61%
0.000371
-1.59%
0.0003306
-11.13%
0.0889
-0.11%
0.0480
0.42%
0.3574
1.48%
0.000398
6.42%
0.3731
5.13%
0.02746
-3.92%
0.11141
-0.01%
0.03551
3.89%
0.00101
8.60%
0.04623
-11.47%
7.7949
2.84%
0.01921
-6.43%
0.002087
0.43%
0.01467
-0.14%
0.06683
-2.92%
0.002225
-25.83%
0.000221
-7.14%
0.3463
11.39%
0.00000003863
-5.06%
0.002266
104.70%
0.695
0.87%
0.08557
-3.70%
0.001018
1.19%
0.0002139
1.52%
0.2975
-1.72%
0.01208
54.48%
19.9519
1.77%
0.5301
5.12%
0.1210
4.13%
0.06034
-9.33%
3057.41
0.78%
0.0025
0.00%
0.00240
-10.78%
0.0000087
-2.25%
0.000098
0.00%
0.02009
-2.76%
0.000002980
-7.54%
0.001584
3.73%
0.001021
-13.62%
0.0000225
-4.26%
0.280
-1.06%
0.0091
-9.90%
0.06165
1.72%
0.2016
7.06%
0.001114
3.34%
0.01149
-21.62%
1.1645
2.10%
0.27454
0.74%
0.014028
0.03%
0.01293
2.46%
0.0000050
-9.09%
0.005539
-0.27%
0.00496
0.40%
0.007353
6.95%
10.67
3.29%
0.000552
1.10%
0.001116
-10.43%
0.60730
5.25%
0.000827
6.03%
0.01019
6.48%
0.5787
0.70%
0.00000000009338
2.10%
0.006874
13.21%
0.000000583
7.76%
0.0002878
2.57%
0.001453
-10.97%
0.07612
-8.00%
0.2893
8.51%
1.5838
8.72%
0.1443
5.10%
0.1027
2.70%
0.2623
0.85%
0.1924
-0.41%
8.862
15.81%
0.00006568
1.31%
6.19
0.65%
0.0066
-1.49%
0.003711
5.79%
0.07287
-0.53%
0.000113
3.67%
3026
0.27%
0.002136
6.48%
0.00000008525
6.95%
0.116397
-9.11%
0.01194
0.25%
0.686
2.69%
1.3274
0.02%
0.01068
-1.93%
0.002589
1.21%
0.00925
8.95%
0.0877
2.10%
0.001219
1.84%
0.00235
-47.54%
0.002604
-12.09%
0.00001323
-2.07%
0.3075
-1.09%
0.1101
1.19%
0.0042
0.00%
170.81
2.84%
13.92
-3.93%
0.004427
1.40%
0.009757
-10.22%
0.00002566
7.77%
1.046
2.65%
0.1508
0.73%
0.0798
-1.60%
0.0006591
-3.34%
0.00694
-1.00%
7.053
-0.18%
0.0007646
-3.98%
2.202
-0.50%
1.6595
5.27%
0.06341
1.68%
0.05145
12.78%
0.00008400
4.70%
0.003157
-20.40%
0.6523
6.71%
0.01285
6.73%
0.00004050
-1.00%
0.0241
2.12%
0.003395
13.17%
0.00002678
16.64%
0.362
0.28%
0.00000001583
-8.66%
0.003043
-4.79%
3.522
1.18%
0.3557
2.24%
0.681
6.57%
0.9177
-0.09%
0.0276
-5.15%
0.0007889
-2.68%
0.001849
0.00%
0.560
0.90%
0.5547
-0.88%
0.0706
-2.49%
0.00285
14.00%
0.02585
-3.11%
2.385
-2.77%
0.2803
-0.39%
7.90
-2.35%
0.8031
1.86%
92.09
6.11%
0.017926
2.31%
0.03133
51.13%
0.00909
1.68%
0.012516
-0.02%
0.01749
4.73%
0.04094
3.36%
0.020970
12.22%
0.04036
3.91%
6.6920
-0.82%
0.001606
-8.59%
0.004031
2.81%
0.000834
1.83%
25.1111
23.16%
0.00000001345
3.54%
0.2142
1.28%
0.0000488
-4.31%
0.00846
-6.42%
0.0111
0.91%
0.01431
14.48%
0.002721
4.17%
0.002481
-10.11%
0.0006995
3.51%
0.00003934
-0.18%
0.1922
1.16%
0.0031
3.33%
0.0115
7.48%
0.01448
-1.36%
0.004017
8.98%
0.01761
-3.98%
18.42
-0.05%
0.01154
0.70%
0.00000071500
336.80%
0.0361
1.40%
0.03888
-4.45%
2209.43
0.50%
0.0007793
-13.41%
0.012837
-6.71%
0.0004677
3.96%
0.000000000252
-1.18%
0.003157
-7.82%
0.4959
3.57%
0.0668
1.06%
0.0000000805
-4.05%
0.03197
-0.65%
0.004276
0.61%
0.1605
1.52%
0.003218
-7.61%
0.01857
0.38%
0.0191
1.06%
0.003978
-1.09%
0.05243
9.85%
0.0000724
5.54%
1.521
1.20%
0.000002244
13.33%
0.2114
0.76%
0.3972
-0.48%
0.001608
-3.48%
0.1154
1.14%
0.7628
-0.05%
2.400
7.29%
0.622
-0.80%
0.1086
-2.16%
0.03309
2.60%
0.2682
-3.39%
0.1481
0.47%
0.2554
1.51%
0.0598
1.01%
0.7937
6.74%
0.001646
6.95%
2.274
0.44%
0.000000559
16.22%
0.0002839
2.79%
0.000001681
0.96%
0.769
0.92%
0.897
0.45%
0.007265
0.82%
0.3922
1.82%
0.2227
-2.20%
0.424
-0.93%
0.0106
2.91%
0.05847
1.94%
0.0777
-0.13%
0.0005301
-2.66%
0.1939
-3.00%
0.0000003070
1.29%
0.0000092
-2.13%
0.00010600
-2.23%
0.003434
1.33%
2.219
0.23%
0.00005789
0.98%
0.0315
3.96%
0.001945
4.96%
0.0386
-0.52%
0.01931
6.10%
0.05533
-9.80%
0.0996
-0.70%
23.954
0.85%
0.013000
4.56%
0.001818
-0.60%
0.2158
0.56%
0.0051068
-0.06%
0.0099
0.00%
0.1635
2.51%
0.00009233
-1.41%
0.2265
-0.66%
0.02848
-0.77%
0.001627
-10.11%
0.0542
1.69%
0.0146000
-87.82%
12.37
0.81%
0.1724
4.23%
0.000211307
-4.68%
0.0006477
2.24%
0.004792
2.37%
0.0468
0.43%
0.000090
9.76%
0.0000002725
-31.24%
0.003840
3.20%
0.00257
1.18%
0.7400
1.96%
0.494
-0.40%
0.737
0.55%
0.04327
-2.02%
0.003550
0.82%
0.002850
-3.19%
2.242
5.70%
0.01605
-4.18%
0.831
-0.36%
0.2260
0.67%
0.01800
0.22%
0.0000269
-1.82%
0.005928
8.29%
0.000700
-2.10%
0.03489
11.79%
0.0004570
-9.43%
0.02027
9.92%
0.001182
2.16%
0.01714
2.82%
1294
1.89%
1.952
2.79%
0.0483
5.46%
0.00004914
2.74%
0.1493
0.61%
0.004424
20.28%
0.0000000000000168
-6.15%
0.00000398
-1.24%
0.0948
-0.84%
0.003440
-20.39%
0.00776
-14.82%
0.3208
2.92%
0.001381
4.07%
0.2801
8.19%
0.00022485
-0.14%
0.0000000002083
1.02%
0.0066
-2.94%
0.0567
-12.23%
0.02657
-2.28%
0.0580
3.39%
0.03073
23.46%
0.2155
0.23%
0.001806
-3.68%
0.0683
1.94%
0.723
0.84%
0.1044
0.77%
0.001124
-0.44%
0.810
1.50%
0.1920
0.05%
0.0122
22.00%
0.01290
0.00%
0.000001630
-3.55%
0.00000000001262
0.08%
0.1173
-3.54%
0.00000808
-0.25%
0.000329
-22.95%
0.0116
-6.45%
0.0004706
18.78%
0.00121
-7.63%
0.04317
-5.54%
1.404
1.08%
0.0382
50.39%
79.0
0.64%
0.005403
5.16%
0.8456
0.82%
0.00000000021945
39.85%
0.00000000001721
15.81%
17.424
-0.93%
0.000249
55.63%
0.0816
0.62%
17.82
1.31%
0.1286
-0.39%
0.005251
-0.83%
0.0000000623
0.48%
1.911
-0.16%
0.00000713
0.42%
0.20003
1.86%
0.1569
0.00%
0.1122
2.28%
0.0766
2.41%
0.0954
2.80%
0.03252
-7.77%
0.01203
-2.12%
0.0991
-1.20%
0.02535
1.04%
0.01650
0.49%
0.0000119
4.39%
0.01337
2.14%
0.0000000042630
42.05%
0.000843
96.05%
0.000001608
3.94%
0.01300
-1.44%
0.6494
1.79%
0.2650
-2.65%
0.00650
0.31%
0.001331
3.34%
0.00003
50.00%
0.000024
0.00%
0.00544
1.87%
0.002013
0.25%
0.1098
1.67%
0.00129
24.04%
0.0000002164
0.32%
0.00000000000012
-57.14%
1.238
0.73%
0.000504
44.00%
0.00306
-2.86%
0.1338
-0.59%
0.1183
-2.31%
2.641
-0.41%
0.0001884
55.57%
0.5287
0.09%
0.01686
-1.52%
0.001096
-0.36%
0.0000000159
3.25%
1.4259
3.27%
0.0135
-20.59%
0.0002441
-2.28%
0.1506
6.66%
19.35
-0.77%
0.00618
-0.64%
0.0805
-0.98%
0.0867
-0.46%
0.006046
7.14%
0.0000235
52.60%
0.4135
-4.72%
0.2815
0.72%
0.000000000001779
2.89%
0.0344
0.58%
0.00420
-0.24%
0.671
-0.59%
0.1530
-2.17%
0.0000485
-4.90%
18.06
-0.88%
0.0920
-0.76%
0.000000000710
-1.39%
0.000963
-5.59%
0.013598
-1.46%
0.02980
0.74%
0.0000019
0.00%
0.230000
91.67%
15.58
-0.13%
0.000757
-8.80%
0.000000001891
-0.37%
0.2239
0.95%
1.701
-0.70%
0.0108
8.00%
0.0935
-1.58%
6.509
1.45%
0.05938
3.16%
1.032
3.41%
0.022345
-9.00%
0.000000000409
-40.03%
0.0001
0.00%
0.0045
-10.00%
0.04024
2.26%
0.000000000003823
-12.42%
0.00000000000012
0.00%
498.90
-0.22%
0.0783
16.87%
0.004210
-0.28%
0.0393
1.55%
2.234
1.59%
0.002407
9.01%
0.0381
0.00%
0.00011
266.67%
0.000384
-1.29%
0.0057
-22.97%
3.52
1.73%
0.2120
2.91%
0.0023814
1.94%
0.000024
-4.00%
0.0015
-16.67%
0.00009784
-40.70%
0.02962
0.07%
0.000080
35.59%
0.01702
1.31%
0.0003
-80.00%
0.00000000000177
0.57%
0.05812
0.00%
0.000882
0.92%
0.0000251
-18.51%
0.000000000000957
3.13%
0.0092
16.46%
0.00008997
0.02%
0.000198
2.59%
0.00125
-1.57%
0.0523
6.95%
0.9990
99.88%
0.00805
-6.94%
0.00461
1.54%
0.000000008400
0.00%
0.0000061
0.00%
0.750
36.36%
0.0002402
-13.50%
0.00003069
1.89%
0.008233
0.04%
0.03749
-0.77%
0.0004337
7.86%
0.0006
20.00%
1.0100
2.02%
0.00040
-4.76%
0.00729
-5.32%
0.00014
0.00%
0.000270
-41.68%
0.000025
78.57%
7.1285
6.61%
0.000112
4.67%
0.00000000000038
-5.00%
3.018
-0.46%
9.770
0.00%
0.0009486
6.90%
0.3830
1.00%
0.00713
1.13%
0.00915
6.77%
0.1535
2.20%
0.0959
-0.93%
0.0000099
76.79%
0.000016
-11.11%
0.0000013
85.71%
0.00000000000651
-0.15%
0.0352
0.57%
0.00000926
-15.74%
0.02776
-0.50%
30.69
-0.78%
0.0488
-3.75%
0.002579
-0.15%
0.909
0.66%
0.1344
3.86%
0.00000000000115
-5.74%
0.0000067
-26.37%
1.2667
0.72%
0.001132
-8.71%
0.00000000109
43.42%
0.00041
28.13%
0.00011
10.00%
0.00024
-7.69%
0.0000000000000156
-1.27%
0.000061
84.85%
0.00000000003615
-0.22%
0.467
4.71%
0.000000002047
1.84%
0.00220
-8.33%
0.5292
-1.85%
0.000001600
228.54%
0.1937
0.68%
0.1300
-1.22%
0.477
1.71%
0.03455
-1.12%
0.00000326
-20.29%
3.58
-5.54%
0.0009
0.00%
0.003951
1.86%
0.004016
7.24%
0.002083
8.55%
0.0000000192
-2.54%
0.0010
11.11%
0.00000322
1.58%
1.097
0.64%
0.01306
1.24%
0.0000675
-0.74%
0.000062
40.91%
0.000055
-23.61%
0.0000310
-0.64%
0.000031
10.71%
0.0000082
-7.87%
0.000000000069
-30.30%
0.000000103
4.04%
0.00000000055
0.00%
0.0700
39.44%
0.001801
0.06%
0.0027
0.00%
0.00263
-2.59%
0.004106
-5.02%
0.0004904
-8.10%
0.0005
25.00%
0.00026
-3.70%
0.7000
0.00%
0.00002283
0.66%
0.0000700
-17.26%
0.2979
-0.07%
0.0437
-0.23%
0.00083
3.75%
0.000000000533
-0.37%
0.0795
1.27%
0.006407
1.06%
0.000000000019
72.73%
0.000423
-0.94%
0.3762
3.41%
0.001323
4.58%
0.000446
0.22%
0.0779
-0.51%
3.0640
-1.35%
0.008000
0.00%
0.00000007783
0.00%
0.000561
1.08%
0.3863
4.07%
0.000400
-42.86%
0.000000000747
-6.74%
0.000085
13.33%
50.0000
0.00%
0.000448
-0.88%
0.000000000120
15.38%
0.00000000000288
-0.69%
0.0005
25.00%
0.0012
9.09%
0.000000000782
0.51%
0.022500
0.45%
0.00000055
1.85%
0.0000647
0.31%
0.00000000000097
-3.96%
0.000000000375
0.27%
0.0000329
0.00%
0.00000000002900
73.03%
0.00000000000406
-0.25%
0.00000000003010
64.21%
0.000000000006
50.00%
0.00000091
3.41%
0.000000002344
-5.02%
0.000000039
-2.50%
0.00030000
-14.29%
0.0852
7.71%
0.0000006617
-0.41%
0.0005154
-6.32%
0.0064
3.23%
0.000194111
6.09%
0.000033
-13.16%
3.022
-0.59%
0.00231
-5.33%
0.000026
8.33%
0.0102
18.60%
0.0000017
-43.33%
0.00056
7.69%
0.001034
0.00%
0.00119
21.43%
0.0562
28.60%
0.00000012
0.00%
0.000307
27.39%
0.0013
116.67%
0.00023
9.52%
0.0609
-7.45%
0.0000010
42.86%
0.00000044
0.00%
0.0003220
0.00%
0.0568
8.40%
0.000817
-1.80%
0.01622
-0.25%
0.0003961
1.85%
0.4867
2.72%
0.10553
0.10%
0.0574
0.00%
0.1427
-2.26%
0.00742
-9.07%
0.01236
10.55%
0.2421
3.07%
58.5600
0.00%
0.0001549
6.68%
0.0004714
-3.91%
0.002862
8.12%
0.00371
0.00%
0.0009012
0.00%
0.13416
-0.10%
0.003456
0.82%
0.0004144
-4.21%
0.00600
0.00%
0.0007993
0.00%
6.309
2.90%
0.05253
-0.76%
0.033603
-2.99%
0.02050
4.81%
0.02364
-2.35%
0.0000397
0.00%
0.002935
0.41%
0.7869
0.94%
1899.00
0.00%
0.4419
-8.03%
1.27
-17.53%
0.6130
5.65%
0.0459
3.85%
0.03066
-0.65%
0.00407
5.17%
0.01157
-2.28%
0.2134
0.33%
2.5129
0.00%
1.000000
0.00%
0.3771
0.00%
0.5732
0.00%
50.556
1.07%
0.0578
-0.52%
0.000000100
0.00%
0.0001030
0.00%
0.00103
0.00%
0.6373
-0.34%
0.0700
0.00%
0.001171
0.60%
0.1535
3.79%
0.01943
1.57%
0.00004399
0.00%
0.000216
0.00%
0.544
1.49%
2.179
0.00%
1.5000
0.00%
3.9889
0.00%
1.1371
0.00%
0.000075
-5.06%
0.4424
0.00%
0.000394
-1.25%
0.06010
0.28%
0.9745
0.00%
0.0071
0.00%
0.000210
0.00%
0.1156
0.96%
0.01448
-0.07%
0.0265
-0.75%
0.1771
-0.06%
8.20
0.74%
0.004326
1.29%
0.3355
0.63%
0.000452
0.00%
0.0132
3.94%
0.0272
0.00%
0.1204
0.00%
0.006000
0.00%
0.000300
0.00%
0.00013
0.00%
0.00035
0.00%
0.0004
0.00%
0.00033
0.00%
0.011926
0.00%
0.000014
0.00%
0.001100
0.00%
0.000365
0.00%
0.001201
0.00%
0.0064
0.00%
0.0000002593
0.00%
0.000009
0.00%
0.00001584
0.00%
0.0000001013
0.00%
0.00005
0.00%
0.00006187
0.00%
0.000166
0.00%
0.001405
0.00%
0.2471
0.12%
0.000480
1.27%
0.000902
0.00%
0.0234
-7.87%
0.0001
0.00%
0.0009
0.00%
0.0560
0.00%
0.00012800
0.00%
0.004025
0.00%
0.0118
7.27%
0.00000100
0.00%
0.0000000104
0.00%
0.000685
0.00%
0.00000006
0.00%
0.001000
0.00%
0.0000000053
0.00%
0.0000000039
0.00%
0.00001626
0.00%
0.0065
0.00%
0.000310
0.00%
0.3284
0.00%
0.9500
0.00%
0.000405
0.00%
----
0.001290
0.00%
0.00000011
0.00%
0.00023846
0.00%
0.000758
0.00%
0.001000
0.00%
0.000058
0.00%
1.6799
0.00%
0.00000000002387
0.00%
0.00425
0.00%
0.00001
0.00%
0.00004
0.00%
0.000118
0.00%
0.0010
0.00%
0.0000241
-4.37%
0.00037
0.00%
0.001963
0.00%
0.00000055
0.00%
0.2994
0.00%
0.00006767
0.00%
0.00005458
0.00%
0.001263
0.00%
0.001210
0.00%
0.00171
0.00%
0.0072
0.00%
0.0001000
0.00%
0.05056
0.00%
1.3575
0.00%
0.00136
0.00%
0.000086
0.00%
0.00007
0.00%
0.000033
0.00%
0.001234
0.00%
0.000449
0.00%
0.0066
0.00%
0.0012
0.00%
0.0004
0.00%
0.0007
0.00%
0.0240
0.00%
0.000522
0.00%
0.020562
0.00%
0.0000111
0.00%
0.007000
0.00%
0.000363
0.00%
0.0012
0.00%
0.000792
0.00%
0.001200
0.00%
0.000331
0.00%
0.001050
0.00%
0.000383
0.00%
4.0009
0.00%
0.01595
0.00%
0.001000
0.00%
0.0786
0.00%
0.001563
0.00%
1.6349
0.00%
0.001790
0.00%
0.00000000000540
0.00%
0.000028
0.00%
0.000999
0.00%
0.0200
0.00%
0.0093
0.00%
0.0006
0.00%
65.1101
0.00%
1.432
3.39%
3.7189
0.00%
0.003015
0.00%
0.000082
0.00%
0.0070
-2.78%
0.016111
0.00%
4.1000
0.00%
0.0489
0.00%
0.0350
0.00%
0.0131
0.00%
4.4022
0.00%
0.0745
0.00%
0.002461
0.00%
0.001160
0.00%
0.001100
0.00%
0.3882
0.00%
0.001000
0.00%
0.076250
0.00%
0.020595
0.00%
0.0150
0.00%
0.002393
0.00%
0.0036
0.00%
0.001978
1.85%
0.1769
0.00%
2.2915
0.00%
0.000257
0.00%
0.000620
0.00%
0.03000
0.00%
0.000946
0.00%
0.4820
0.00%
0.0490
0.00%
0.0096
0.00%
0.0060
0.00%
0.04500
0.00%
0.000259
0.00%
12.1000
0.00%
1.76670591
0.00%
0.0024
0.00%
0.000399
0.00%
0.0001403
0.00%
0.0000000000270
0.00%
0.0000002850
0.00%
0.6700
0.00%
0.00007
0.00%
0.01989
0.00%
0.0026
0.00%
0.2888
0.00%
0.00501
0.00%
0.02700
0.00%
0.0650
0.00%
0.3515
0.00%
0.00125
0.00%
0.4900
0.00%
0.5000
0.00%
0.010100
0.00%
0.0069
0.00%
0.88686
0.00%
0.00084
0.00%
0.0000285
0.00%
0.05578
0.00%
1.1760
0.00%
0.00689
0.00%
0.1725
0.00%
0.00010
0.00%
0.01463
0.00%
0.00614
0.00%
0.04851
0.00%
0.4606
0.00%
0.001800
0.00%
0.00006
0.00%
0.01200
0.00%
0.00010
0.00%
0.000001000
0.00%
0.0182
0.00%
101.67
0.00%
0.0000008
0.00%
1.3302
1.08%
0.01050
0.00%
0.00390
0.00%
0.0000325
0.00%
1.0000
0.00%
0.34211
0.00%
0.00132
0.00%
0.0000077
0.00%
0.0005
0.00%
0.1495
0.00%
0.00146
0.00%
0.00036
0.00%
0.001277
0.00%
0.03520
0.00%
0.0000023
0.00%
0.000000005
0.00%
0.000514
0.00%
0.001987
0.00%
0.000313
0.00%
0.0000029
0.00%
0.0007000
0.00%
0.00200
0.00%
0.0032
0.00%
0.3131
0.00%
0.000495
0.00%
0.00049
0.00%
0.300
0.00%
0.00017800
0.00%
0.007210
0.00%
0.00635
0.00%
0.0900
0.00%
0.00006
0.00%
0.000000000009
0.00%
0.000506
0.00%
0.01030
0.00%
0.00070
0.00%
0.003000
0.00%
0.000310
0.00%
0.0000269
0.00%
0.0000000500
0.00%
0.0000001300
0.00%
0.000996
0.00%
0.7997
0.00%
0.0001543
0.00%
0.000000000128
0.00%
0.000426832
0.00%
0.00002805
0.00%
0.1600
0.00%
0.0000245
0.00%
0.000056
0.00%
0.1197
0.00%
0.000510
0.00%
0.00218
0.00%
0.002100
0.00%
0.3101
0.00%
0.0000305
0.00%
0.00639
0.00%
0.4400
0.00%
1.4371
0.00%
0.000196
-0.51%
0.250
0.00%
0.4289
1.23%
0.3893
1.06%
0.001106
0.00%
0.0249
0.00%
0.6608
0.00%
0.0609
0.66%
0.00500
0.00%
0.0020
0.00%
0.00538
0.00%
0.4583
0.75%
0.000000001869
0.00%
5155.00
0.00%
1.519
-0.33%
0.0091
0.00%